Mailing Evidence for Small Claims Court (2025 Guide)

Organizing small claims court evidence and certified mail records for trial

Quick Answer: Small Claims Court Mailing

Before filing: Send demand letter by certified mail
Serving defendant: Check if your court allows certified mail service
Key evidence: Certified mail receipts proving you contacted defendant
At trial: Bring copies of all documents and receipts

Small claims court is designed for people to represent themselves in disputes involving relatively small amounts of money. Proper documentation is crucial to winning your case, and much of that documentation involves mailing. This guide explains how to use certified mail throughout the small claims court process—from sending a demand letter to serving the defendant to presenting evidence at trial.

USPS Delivery Time Estimator

Choose your sending and destination states to estimate how long First-Class and Priority Mail usually take to arrive.

Open the estimator

Small Claims Court Overview

Small claims courts handle civil disputes up to certain dollar limits (varies by state):

State	Small Claims Limit
California	$12,500 ($6,250 for businesses)
Texas	$20,000
New York	$10,000
Florida	$8,000

Dollar limits vary by state and can change over time. Always confirm current limits with your local court or state judiciary website.

Common small claims cases include: unpaid debts, security deposit disputes, breach of contract, property damage, defective products/services, and landlord-tenant issues.

Step 1: Send a Demand Letter

Before filing in small claims court, you should send a demand letter to the defendant. This is important because:

Shows good faith: Demonstrates you tried to resolve the dispute first
May avoid court: The defendant might pay to avoid litigation
Expected by judges: Many judges ask if you contacted the defendant before suing
Creates evidence: The certified mail receipt proves you made the attempt

Demand Letter Checklist

• State the facts of your dispute clearly
• Specify the exact amount you are owed
• Reference any contracts or agreements
• Set a deadline for response (typically 10-30 days)
• State you will file in small claims court if not resolved
• Send by certified mail with return receipt
• Keep a copy for your records

For detailed instructions, see our demand letter guide. For tips on documenting that you sent the letter, see How to Prove You Mailed Something.

Step 2: File Your Claim

If the demand letter does not resolve the dispute, file your small claims case:

Where to File

File in the county where the defendant lives or where the dispute occurred. Check your local court's website for the correct courthouse.

Filing Fee

Fees typically range from $30-$100+ depending on the amount claimed and jurisdiction. You can often request this be added to your judgment if you win.

What You'll Need

Defendant's name and address, description of your claim, amount you're seeking, and your contact information.

Step 3: Serve the Defendant

After filing, the defendant must be notified of the lawsuit. Service methods vary by jurisdiction:

Service Method	How It Works
Court Clerk Mails	The clerk mails notice by certified mail (common in many states)
Plaintiff Mails	You mail by certified mail and file proof of service
Personal Service	Someone (not you) hand-delivers to defendant
Sheriff/Process Server	Sheriff or professional server delivers (may have fee)

Check Your Court's Rules

Service rules vary significantly. Some courts handle service automatically; others require you to arrange it. Contact your court clerk or check the court's website for specific instructions.

Organizing Your Evidence

Good evidence wins small claims cases. Organize these items:

Written Agreements

• Contracts (signed by both parties)
• Leases or rental agreements
• Invoices and estimates
• Warranties and guarantees

Payment Records

• Receipts
• Canceled checks (front and back)
• Credit card statements
• Bank statements showing payments

Communications

• Emails and text messages
• Letters sent and received
• Demand letter and response (if any)
• Certified mail receipts (proving you sent notices)

Visual Evidence

• Photos (with dates if possible)
• Videos
• Diagrams or sketches

Supporting Documents

• Repair estimates from third parties
• Expert opinions
• Witness statements

Certified Mail as Evidence

Your certified mail receipts serve as important evidence in small claims court. For background on how certified mail works, see What Is Certified Mail?

What Certified Mail Proves

PS Form 3800 (Certified Mail Receipt): Proves you mailed documents on a specific date to a specific address
PS Form 3811 (Green Card): Proves the recipient received the documents and when
Tracking Records: Shows the chain of delivery or any refusal/non-delivery
Refused/Unclaimed Status: Shows you made the effort even if they did not accept (see Return to Sender for what to do if mail comes back)

Evidence Checklist: Certified Mail Records

□ Copy of demand letter you sent
□ Certified mail receipt (PS Form 3800)
□ Return receipt (green card) - original
□ Printed tracking records from USPS
□ Any returned/refused mail (keep unopened)

Preparing for Trial

Get your evidence organized before your court date:

Make Copies

• Original for you
• Copy for the judge
• Copy for the defendant

Organize Chronologically

Put documents in order by date. This helps you tell your story clearly and find documents quickly when the judge asks questions.

Create an Index

List each document with a brief description. This helps you reference "Exhibit 3" instead of shuffling through papers.

Prepare Your Presentation

• Practice summarizing your case in 2-3 minutes
• Know which document supports each part of your claim
• Be ready to explain why you sent the demand letter by certified mail

Common Things Judges Ask

• "Did you try to resolve this before coming to court?"
• "Did you send a demand letter?"
• "Do you have proof the defendant received your communications?"
• "What is your documentation for this claim?"

Your certified mail receipts help answer these questions.

Send Your Demand Letter by Certified Mail

Skip the post office. Upload your demand letter and we print and send it via USPS Certified Mail with Return Receipt. Same-day processing, full tracking, and proof of delivery for your small claims case.

Send Certified Mail Online

FAQs

Can I serve small claims court papers by certified mail?

Many small claims courts allow service by certified mail, either by the plaintiff directly or through the court clerk. However, rules vary by jurisdiction. Check your local court's rules to confirm what service methods are permitted.

What evidence should I bring to small claims court?

Bring: the original contract or agreement, receipts and invoices, photographs, written correspondence (including your demand letter and certified mail receipts), witness statements, and any other documentation supporting your claim. Make copies for the judge and defendant.

Do I need to send a demand letter before small claims court?

While not always legally required, sending a demand letter before filing is strongly recommended. It shows good faith effort to resolve the dispute and many judges expect to see that you tried to settle before suing. Certified mail proof is important.

How do I prove I sent documents to the defendant?

Use certified mail with return receipt. The certified mail receipt (PS Form 3800) proves you mailed the documents, and the return receipt (green card) proves delivery. Bring these receipts to court as evidence.

What if the defendant never received my demand letter?

If your certified mail was returned unclaimed or refused, you still have proof that you attempted to contact them. Bring the returned envelope (unopened) and tracking records to court. This shows you made a good faith effort.

How many copies of evidence do I need?

Bring at least three copies of everything: one for yourself, one for the judge, and one for the defendant. Some courts may require additional copies. Check with your court clerk.

Is certified mail enough proof of service in small claims court?

In many jurisdictions, certified mail with return receipt is accepted as valid proof of service for small claims court. However, requirements vary by court. Some courts require personal service for initial filings but accept certified mail for subsequent documents. Check your local court rules or ask the clerk what service methods are permitted.

Related Guides

Legal Disclaimer

This guide provides general information about small claims court procedures and is not legal advice. Small claims court rules vary significantly by jurisdiction. For specific legal advice about your small claims case, consult with a licensed attorney or contact your local court's self-help center.

Last updated: January 25, 2025

Tags: small claims court, mailing evidence small claims court, how to mail evidence to small claims court, demand letter, certified mail evidence, proof of service, small claims filing